broadbenchConfidential

Tax-Efficient Protection
for Your Surgical Career

Simon Boyle

Prepared for Simon Boyle, Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon
Yorkshire Shoulder Clinic · York & Leeds

Prepared by Thomas Hitchcock · Broadbench · March 2026

01

A New Approach to Your Protection

Dear Simon,

Thank you for taking the time to discuss your protection needs with me. Following our conversation, I have reviewed your existing insurance portfolio in detail and prepared a comprehensive tax-efficient protection strategy designed specifically for your circumstances as a Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon.

As a surgeon, your ability to earn is uniquely dependent on your physical health — specifically, the precision and dexterity of your hands, the strength of your shoulders, and the endurance required to perform complex arthroscopic procedures. Research published in the Journal of Surgical Research shows that over 50% of surgeons report sustaining a work-related musculoskeletal injury during their career, with shoulder and neck pain affecting up to 60% of operating surgeons. For a shoulder specialist like yourself, these risks are not hypothetical — they are occupational realities.

Your current portfolio of six policies totals £1,156.09 per month, with an estimated remaining cost of £187,931 to the end of their terms. Critically, despite this significant outlay, you currently have no critical illness cover whatsoever — a substantial gap for someone whose income depends entirely on their physical ability to operate.

Surgeon performing a procedure — precision and dexterity are essential

I have designed a three-pillar strategy that restructures your protection through your limited company, unlocking 19% corporation tax relief on every premium while simultaneously adding the critical illness and key person cover you are currently missing. The three pillars are:

1

Relevant Life Insurance

Via Vitality — life cover paid as a business expense with full tax relief

2

Key Person Protection

Via Vitality — serious illness cover 3x protecting your business and surgical career

3

Income Protection

Via Legal & General — own-occupation cover ensuring income if you cannot operate

I have recommended Vitality specifically because of their Business Serious Illness Cover — a severity-based product that pays proportionate to the impact of a condition rather than on an all-or-nothing basis. With 167 conditions covered (Business SIC Plus), severity-graded payouts from 5% to 100%, and the 3x claim feature that allows claims to be paid until the whole cover amount is used up, this is the most comprehensive business protection product available for a surgeon facing multiple occupational health risks throughout a long career.

02

Existing Portfolio Review

You currently hold six separate policies across income protection and life cover, all with Aviva. While these provide a foundation of protection, there are significant gaps — most notably, the complete absence of critical illness cover.

Critical Gap Identified

Despite paying £1,156.09 per month, you currently have zero critical illness cover. As a surgeon whose career depends on physical health, a serious illness diagnosis could end your ability to operate without any financial safety net beyond income protection.

Income Protection Cover

Aviva · Simon Boyle

£153.64
Benefit

£3,388.45/month

Deferred

13 weeks

Duration

Aug 2018 – Apr 2039

Est. Remaining

£24,320

Income Protection+

Aviva · Simon Boyle

£227.14
Benefit

£6,068.50/month

Deferred

26/52 weeks

Duration

Aug 2018 – Apr 2039

Est. Remaining

£35,954

Income Protection

Aviva · Simon & Helen

£162.05
Benefit

£3,003/month

Deferred

52 weeks

Duration

Aug 2012 – Apr 2039

Est. Remaining

£25,649

Life Cover

Aviva · Simon & Helen

£151.39
Benefit

£458,697 lump sum

Deferred

Duration

Aug 2018 – Aug 2043

Est. Remaining

£31,843

Life Assurance (Decreasing)

Aviva · Simon Boyle

£37.37
Benefit

£75,787 lump sum

Deferred

Duration

Dec 2004 – Nov 2029

Est. Remaining

£1,694

Life Insurance+

Aviva · Simon & Helen

£424.50
Benefit

£528,771 lump sum

Deferred

Duration

Aug 2018 – Jul 2039

Est. Remaining

£68,470

Total Life Cover

£1,063,255

Total IP Benefit

£12,460/mo

Monthly Cost

£1,156.09

Critical Illness

£0

03

Relevant Life Insurance

The following quotations are for a Vitality Relevant Life Insurance policy, paid by your business as a tax-deductible expense. All premiums are index-linked, meaning both the cover amount and premium will increase annually in line with inflation. Proceeds are written into trust, meaning no further tax on payout.

Your current life cover totals £1,063,255 across three personal policies costing £613.26 per month from personal income. The options below demonstrate how a Relevant Life policy through your business offers superior value with full corporation tax relief.

Quotes for Simon Boyle

To Age 65

Option 1

£750,000

Cover to age 65

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£113.12
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£91.63
Daily Cost (20 working days)£4.58
Recommended

Option 2

£1,000,000

Cover to age 65

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£150.83
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£122.17
Daily Cost (20 working days)£6.11

Option 3

£1,250,000

Cover to age 65

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£188.54
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£152.72
Daily Cost (20 working days)£7.64

To Age 70

Option 1

£750,000

Cover to age 70

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£142.76
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£115.64
Daily Cost (20 working days)£5.78
Recommended

Option 2

£1,000,000

Cover to age 70

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£190.35
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£154.18
Daily Cost (20 working days)£7.71

Option 3

£1,250,000

Cover to age 70

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£237.93
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£192.72
Daily Cost (20 working days)£9.64

Quotes for Helen Pentelow-Boyle

To Age 65

Option 1

£750,000

Cover to age 65

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£107.26
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£86.88
Daily Cost (20 working days)£4.34
Recommended

Option 2

£1,000,000

Cover to age 65

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£143.01
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£115.84
Daily Cost (20 working days)£5.79

Option 3

£1,250,000

Cover to age 65

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£178.76
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£144.80
Daily Cost (20 working days)£7.24

To Age 70

Option 1

£750,000

Cover to age 70

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£135.73
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£109.94
Daily Cost (20 working days)£5.50
Recommended

Option 2

£1,000,000

Cover to age 70

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£180.98
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£146.59
Daily Cost (20 working days)£7.33

Option 3

£1,250,000

Cover to age 70

Index-Linked

Monthly Premium£226.22
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£183.24
Daily Cost (20 working days)£9.16

Corporation Tax Relief

As a business expense paid through your limited company, these premiums qualify for 19% corporation tax relief. The "After Corp Tax Relief" figures above show your true net cost. This makes business protection one of the most tax-efficient ways to secure life cover.

My Recommendation

Age 70 Term

As we discussed, the longer the policy is in place, the higher the statistical chance of it paying out. By taking the policy to age 70, you lock in today's pricing for the maximum useful period. You can always reduce the cover or shorten the term later — but you cannot extend it without re-applying at an older age and higher cost.

04

Vitality Business SIC 3x

This is the critical gap in your current portfolio. As the sole operating surgeon at Yorkshire Shoulder Clinic, you are the business. Vitality's Business Serious Illness Cover 3x protects your company against the financial impact of you being unable to operate — covering 167 conditions across seven severity tiers, with the ability to claim up to three times your sum assured over the life of the policy.

With 3x cover, claims can be paid until the whole cover amount is used up. If a condition worsens, you can claim again. If you recover and later develop a new, unrelated illness, the remaining cover is still available. For a surgeon whose career could span another 15–20 years, this multi-claim capability provides genuinely layered protection — a single policy working hard across the full arc of your career.

Crucially, this is a Business Protection policy — premiums are paid by Yorkshire Shoulder Clinic Ltd and may be Corporation Tax deductible, making the real cost significantly lower than the quoted premium. The payout goes to your company, protecting against the financial impact of your absence from practice.

Your Quotes — Business SIC 3x (Indexed)

To Age 65

£100,000

Cover to age 65 · Business SIC 3x · Indexed

Monthly Premium£132.46
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£107.29
Daily Cost (20 working days)£5.36
Recommended

£200,000

Cover to age 65 · Business SIC 3x · Indexed

Monthly Premium£275.88
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£223.46
Daily Cost (20 working days)£11.17

£300,000

Cover to age 65 · Business SIC 3x · Indexed

Monthly Premium£361.04
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£292.44
Daily Cost (20 working days)£14.62

To Age 70

£100,000

Cover to age 70 · Business SIC 3x · Indexed

Monthly Premium£173.34
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£140.41
Daily Cost (20 working days)£7.02
Recommended

£200,000

Cover to age 70 · Business SIC 3x · Indexed

Monthly Premium£328.58
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£266.15
Daily Cost (20 working days)£13.31

£300,000

Cover to age 70 · Business SIC 3x · Indexed

Monthly Premium£481.71
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£390.19
Daily Cost (20 working days)£19.51

Seven Severity Tiers — How Vitality Pays

100%

Life-Threatening

75%

Severe

50%

Moderate

25%

Significant

15%

Early-Stage

10%

Minor

5%

Initial

Traditional critical illness cover pays 100% or nothing. Vitality pays across all seven tiers — meaning partial conditions that affect your surgical ability still trigger a claim. A traditional policy would pay £0 for a 25% severity condition; Vitality pays 25% of your sum assured.

Areas of Cover — Relevant to Your Surgical Career

Of the 167 conditions covered under Business SIC 3x, the following are most directly relevant to a Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon. These are the conditions that could end or significantly curtail your operating practice — many of which would not be covered at all by a traditional critical illness policy.

DEXTERITY

Hands, Dexterity & Upper Limb

The conditions most likely to end a surgical career — directly affecting the precision required for arthroscopic and open shoulder procedures.

Peripheral Neuropathy

25–100%

Nerve damage causing loss of sensation or motor control in the hands. For a shoulder surgeon performing complex arthroscopic repairs, even mild peripheral neuropathy can make precision instrument work impossible.

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (Severe)

25%

Severe compression of the median nerve requiring surgical intervention. Vitality covers this at 25% — a traditional CIC policy would not pay out at all, as it does not meet the 'critical' threshold.

Dupuytren's Contracture

25%

Progressive fibrosis of the palmar fascia causing finger contracture. Particularly relevant for surgeons who spend hours in the operating theatre — covered by Vitality where standard CIC would decline.

Rheumatoid Arthritis

25–75%

Covered from diagnosis under Vitality's SIC 3x — not just at severe stages. Early-stage RA affecting grip strength and fine motor control would qualify for a partial payout, protecting your income before the condition becomes debilitating.

Complex Regional Pain Syndrome

50–100%

A chronic pain condition following injury or surgery, often affecting the upper limb. Can render a surgeon unable to operate even without visible structural damage — covered under Vitality's broader definition.

NEUROLOGICAL

Neurological Conditions

Neurological events that affect cognitive function, coordination, or motor control — all of which are essential to safe surgical practice.

Stroke

25–100%

Covered from 25% severity (minor stroke with measurable neurological deficit) through to 100% (major stroke with permanent disability). Even a minor stroke affecting fine motor coordination could prevent you from returning to theatre.

Multiple Sclerosis

25–100%

Covered from diagnosis. MS can cause tremor, weakness, and coordination problems that directly affect surgical precision — Vitality pays out at earlier stages than traditional CIC, which typically requires permanent disability.

Parkinson's Disease

50–100%

Covered from confirmed diagnosis. The characteristic tremor of Parkinson's is incompatible with surgical practice — this would trigger a full claim under the own-occupation definition of the associated income protection.

Benign Brain Tumour

25–100%

Covered regardless of whether it requires surgery. A benign tumour affecting motor or sensory areas could end a surgical career without being 'life-threatening' in the traditional sense.

Traumatic Brain Injury

25–100%

Covered at severity-appropriate levels. Post-concussion syndrome affecting concentration and coordination — common after road traffic accidents — would qualify for a partial payout.

MUSCULOSKELETAL

Musculoskeletal & Spinal

Particularly relevant given your specialism — the conditions you treat in patients are the same ones that could affect your ability to operate.

Spinal Cord Injury

50–100%

Any injury causing permanent neurological deficit is covered. For a surgeon who spends long hours in fixed operating positions, spinal conditions are a genuine occupational risk.

Severe Osteoarthritis

25–50%

Covered where it causes significant functional limitation. Osteoarthritis of the shoulder, elbow, or wrist — the very joints you operate on — is covered where it prevents you from performing your role.

Ankylosing Spondylitis

25–75%

A chronic inflammatory condition of the spine causing progressive stiffness. Surgeons who stand for hours in fixed positions are at elevated risk of spinal conditions — covered at multiple severity levels.

Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

25–75%

An autoimmune condition affecting joints, skin, and organs. SLE affecting hand and joint function would qualify for a partial claim under Vitality's broader condition definitions.

CANCER

Cancer

The single largest cause of critical illness claims (69.6% of all Vitality CI claims in 2024). Vitality pays out at earlier stages than any other UK insurer.

Early-Stage Cancer

15–25%

Vitality pays 15% for low-grade prostate cancer and ductal carcinoma in situ — conditions that would not trigger a traditional CIC policy at all. Even a brief period away from theatre for treatment is financially protected.

Cancer Requiring Treatment

50–100%

Any cancer requiring chemotherapy, radiotherapy, or surgery triggers a mid-to-full payout. Treatment side-effects — fatigue, neuropathy, cognitive changes — can prevent a return to operating for months.

Cancer Relapse

50–100%

Vitality's 3x feature means a cancer relapse can trigger a second or third claim, even after a full initial payout. This is unique to Vitality — no other UK insurer offers this level of repeat-claim protection.

CARDIOVASCULAR

Cardiovascular

Heart and vascular conditions that could require extended recovery periods incompatible with a return to the operating theatre.

Heart Attack

25–100%

Covered from 25% (minor heart attack with measurable cardiac enzyme rise) to 100% (major MI with significant left ventricular dysfunction). Even a minor cardiac event requiring medication and monitoring could prevent operating for 3–6 months.

Coronary Artery Bypass

75%

A 75% payout on confirmed bypass surgery. Recovery from CABG typically takes 3–6 months before a return to physically demanding work — the payout provides financial stability during that period.

Heart Valve Replacement

75%

Covered at 75% severity. Post-operative anticoagulation and recovery from valve surgery would prevent a return to operating for an extended period.

Aortic Surgery

50–75%

Major aortic procedures are covered at 50–75% severity. The recovery period and ongoing monitoring requirements would significantly affect your ability to maintain a surgical practice.

Total Permanent Disability

Definition — Own Occupation

Total Permanent Disability under Vitality's Business SIC 3x is defined as the permanent and irreversible inability to perform your own occupation — assessed specifically against your role as a Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon, not a generic medical practitioner.

1

Own-Occupation Assessment

TPD is assessed against your specific surgical role. If you are permanently unable to perform arthroscopic shoulder procedures, open shoulder reconstructions, or elbow surgeries — the procedures that define your practice — you qualify for a full 100% payout, even if you could theoretically work in a non-surgical medical capacity.

2

Partial Permanent Disability

Unlike traditional CIC policies that only pay on total permanent disability, Vitality's SIC 3x also covers partial permanent disability at 25–75% severity. If a condition permanently reduces your surgical capacity — for example, limiting you to one operating list per week instead of four — you receive a proportionate payout.

3

Guaranteed Insurability

Business SIC 3x includes Guaranteed Insurability Options, allowing the cover amount to be increased at certain life events — such as a significant increase in business revenue — without the need for further medical underwriting. This is particularly valuable as Yorkshire Shoulder Clinic grows.

4

Multiple Claims Without Lapsing

After a successful claim, the policy remains in force for subsequent claims — you are not left uninsured and uninsurable after your first payout. This is a core differentiator of Business SIC 3x versus traditional Key Person critical illness policies.

3x

Multiple Claims — How It Works in Practice

Claims can be paid until the whole cover amount is used up. Consider a scenario: at age 53 you are diagnosed with early-stage prostate cancer (15% payout = £30,000 on £200k cover). You recover, return to theatre, and at age 58 develop severe carpal tunnel syndrome requiring surgery (25% payout = £50,000). You still have £120,000 of remaining cover for any future claim. A traditional CIC policy would have paid nothing for either of these conditions.

30%

of small businesses fail within 5 years

42%

cite unexpected loss of a key person as the cause

12%

of small business owners have key person cover

6x

average cost of replacing a key person vs salary

06

Why We Recommend Vitality

Vitality's Business Serious Illness Cover stands apart from the market in three critical ways: the breadth of conditions covered, the severity-graded payout structure (A–G, paying 5%–100%), and the 3x claim feature that allows claims to be paid until the whole cover amount is used up. For a surgeon whose career spans decades and faces multiple occupational health risks, these advantages are substantial.

 
Vitality
Industry Average
Conditions Covered (Business SIC Plus)
167
~50
Severity Grades
A–G (5%–100%)
All or nothing
3x Claim Feature
Yes
No
Early-Stage Cancer Cover
Yes (15%+)
Rarely
Partial Disability Cover
Yes
Limited
Musculoskeletal Conditions
Covered
Often excluded

Severity-Based Payouts

Unlike traditional critical illness policies that only pay on the most severe diagnoses, Vitality Business SIC pays across seven severity grades (A–G). This is particularly valuable for a surgeon — conditions that may not be "critical" in the traditional sense could still end your surgical career.

100%ALife-Threatening

Advanced cancer, major stroke, heart attack requiring bypass

75%BSevere

Moderate stroke, coronary artery bypass, major organ transplant

50%CModerate

Early-stage cancer, carotid endarterectomy, aortic surgery

25%DSignificant

Carcinoma in situ, coronary angioplasty, peripheral neuropathy

15%EEarly-Stage

Low-grade prostate cancer, ductal carcinoma in situ, early melanoma

10%FPartial / Functional

Partial loss of limb function, early neurological changes, limited joint mobility

5%GInitial Diagnosis

Early-stage conditions, pre-surgical diagnoses, initial functional impairment

Conditions Particularly Relevant to Surgeons

Neurological

  • • Peripheral neuropathy
  • • Multiple sclerosis
  • • Motor neurone disease
  • • Parkinson's disease

Musculoskeletal

  • • Rheumatoid arthritis
  • • Severe osteoarthritis
  • • Systemic lupus erythematosus
  • • Ankylosing spondylitis

Cardiovascular

  • • Heart attack
  • • Stroke
  • • Coronary artery bypass
  • • Aortic surgery
07

Vitality Claims Data

In 2024, Vitality paid out £142 million in protection claims. Their claims data demonstrates why critical illness cover is essential — and why the breadth of conditions covered matters.

£142m

Total claims paid in 2024

Across all protection products

69.6%

Of critical illness claims were cancer

The single largest cause of claims

167

Conditions covered

Business SIC Plus — A–G severity grades

Top Claim Conditions

Cancer69.6%
Heart Conditions12.8%
Stroke5.2%
Neurological4.1%
Other8.3%

What This Means for You

As a 51-year-old male, your statistical risk of critical illness increases significantly over the next 15–20 years. Cancer alone accounts for nearly 70% of all critical illness claims. With Vitality Business SIC Plus covering 167 conditions across seven severity grades (A–G, paying 5%–100%) — more than standard market critical illness cover — you would be protected against the broadest possible range of diagnoses: from early-stage cancers that might only require a brief absence from theatre, to life-threatening conditions requiring extensive treatment. With the 3x claim feature, claims can be paid until the whole cover amount is used up, meaning your protection continues to work for you even after an initial claim.

05

Legal & General Executive IP

Your current income protection across three Aviva policies provides £12,460 per month in combined benefit, costing £542.83 per month — paid personally, with no tax relief. The Legal & General Executive Income Protection below provides £10,000 per month through your company, with full Corporation Tax relief on premiums, an own-occupation definition specific to your surgical role, and a single consolidated policy replacing three.

The own-occupation definition is the most important feature of any income protection policy for a surgeon. It means you are covered if you cannot perform your specific role as a Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon — not just any job, and not just any medical role. This is the gold standard of income protection for medical professionals, and it is what distinguishes this recommendation from a standard policy.

The 13-week deferred period aligns with your existing Aviva policies and is appropriate given the financial reserves of a limited company. Benefit payments continue for up to 2 years per claim — or to age 65/70 on the full-term option — providing sustained income replacement during an extended recovery.

Option 1 — To Age 65

£10,000/month

13-week deferred · 2-year benefit period · Own occupation

Monthly Premium£241.30
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£195.45
Daily Cost£9.77
ProviderLegal & General
DefinitionOwn Occupation
Recommended

Option 2 — To Age 70

£10,000/month

13-week deferred · 2-year benefit period · Own occupation

Monthly Premium£301.67
After Corp Tax Relief (19%)£244.35
Daily Cost£12.22
ProviderLegal & General
DefinitionOwn Occupation
 
Current (3 Aviva policies)
New (L&G Option 2)
Monthly Benefit
£12,460
£10,000
Monthly Cost
£542.83
£301.67
After Tax Relief
N/A (personal)
£244.35
Deferred Period
13 / 26 / 52 weeks
13 weeks
Occupation Definition
Various
Own Occupation
Covers Dividends
No
Yes
Rehab Support
No
Yes (standard)
Number of Policies
3
1

Own-Occupation in Practice — Scenarios for a Surgeon

The following scenarios illustrate how the own-occupation definition works specifically for a Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon. In each case, a standard "any occupation" or "suited occupation" policy would likely deny the claim.

Hand Tremor or Nerve Damage

Claim Paid in Full

A tremor affecting fine motor control, peripheral neuropathy from a spinal condition, or nerve damage following an injury would prevent you from performing arthroscopic procedures. Under own-occupation, L&G pays the full £10,000/month benefit from week 13 — regardless of whether you could work in another medical capacity.

Rotator Cuff Injury (Surgeon's Own)

Claim Paid in Full

Surgeons who perform repetitive overhead and rotational movements are at elevated risk of the very injuries they treat. A significant rotator cuff tear requiring surgery and rehabilitation could take you out of theatre for 6–12 months. Under own-occupation, this qualifies from week 13 of absence.

Cancer Treatment

Claim Paid in Full

Chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and surgical recovery can prevent a return to operating for months. Fatigue, peripheral neuropathy from chemotherapy, and cognitive effects ('chemo brain') are all recognised reasons why a surgeon cannot safely return to theatre — all covered under own-occupation.

Mental Health — Burnout or PTSD

Claim Paid in Full

Mental health accounts for 22.4% of L&G income protection claims. Surgeon burnout, PTSD following a surgical complication, or severe depression are all covered under own-occupation. The psychological demands of operating — particularly in complex shoulder and elbow reconstruction — are significant and recognised.

Spinal Condition

Claim Paid in Full

Surgeons spend hours in fixed, often awkward positions at the operating table. Disc herniation, spinal stenosis, or chronic back pain preventing you from standing at the table for extended periods would qualify under own-occupation — even if you could sit at a desk.

Policy Features in Detail

Own-Occupation Definition

Assessed against your specific role as a Consultant Shoulder & Elbow Surgeon — not a generic 'medical practitioner' or 'any occupation' standard. If you cannot perform arthroscopic shoulder repairs, rotator cuff reconstructions, or elbow procedures, you qualify for the full benefit. You could theoretically work as a GP, a medical consultant, or in private practice in a non-surgical capacity — and L&G would still pay in full.

Covers Salary, Dividends & P11D Benefits

L&G Executive Income Protection covers your total remuneration package — not just your PAYE salary. As a director of Yorkshire Shoulder Clinic Ltd drawing a combination of salary and dividends, this is essential. A policy that only covers your nominal salary would leave a significant gap in your actual income replacement.

Rehabilitation Support Included

L&G includes vocational rehabilitation as standard — a case manager works with you and your medical team to support a return to work where possible. For a surgeon, this could mean a phased return to lighter surgical duties before resuming a full operating list, rather than an all-or-nothing recovery.

RedArc Wellbeing Service

Access to a dedicated registered nurse by telephone — available from day one of a claim, not just after the deferred period. For a surgeon facing a career-threatening diagnosis, having a clinical professional available to navigate treatment options, second opinions, and rehabilitation planning is a genuinely valuable benefit.

Waiver of Premium

Optional Extra

While the policy is on claim, premiums are waived — meaning your protection continues at no cost during the period you need it most. This is particularly important for a long-term claim where the deferred period has passed and benefit payments are running.

Changing Policy Option

Cover can be adjusted as your circumstances change — if your income increases as the clinic grows, or if you wish to extend the benefit period, L&G allows policy adjustments without requiring new medical underwriting in most circumstances.

L&G 2024 Claims Statistics

£1bn+

Total paid in claims in 2024

84%

Income protection claims accepted

38.8%

IP claims — musculoskeletal (No.1 cause)

34 yrs

Longest running income protection claim

Top 3 Causes of L&G Income Protection Claims — 2024

01

Musculoskeletal

38.8%

The single largest cause — directly relevant to a surgeon's occupational risk profile. Shoulder, neck, and back conditions account for the majority of musculoskeletal IP claims.

02

Mental Health

22.4%

Burnout, PTSD, and depression are significant risks in high-pressure surgical environments. Own-occupation cover means a mental health diagnosis preventing safe surgical practice qualifies in full.

03

Cancer

12.1%

Treatment and recovery from cancer frequently prevents a return to operating for extended periods. The 13-week deferred period means benefit begins well within a typical treatment timeline.

08

Protecting What You've Built

Consultant surgeon's office with shoulder imaging on screen

Your Surgical Practice

As the lead surgeon at Yorkshire Shoulder Clinic, you perform complex arthroscopic procedures that require exceptional hand dexterity and physical endurance. You were the first UK surgeon to perform a complex arthroscopic Latarjet shoulder stabilisation — a procedure that demands the highest level of surgical precision. Any condition affecting your hands, shoulders, or neurological function could immediately end your ability to operate. Key Person Protection ensures your business survives if you cannot.

Your Family

You and Helen have built your financial security around your surgical income. Your current life cover of £1,063,255 provides a foundation, but the complete absence of critical illness cover means a serious diagnosis — even one you survive — could devastate your family's finances. The recommended Relevant Life Insurance through your company provides equivalent or greater cover at a lower net cost, while adding the critical illness protection that is currently missing.

Your Current Arrangement

You are currently paying £1,156.09 per month across six separate policies, all from personal income with no tax relief. This is £13,873 per year in after-tax money. By restructuring through your limited company, you unlock 19% corporation tax relief on every premium — immediately reducing your effective cost. Additionally, consolidating from six policies to three simplifies your portfolio and eliminates overlapping cover.

The Bottom Line

Your current portfolio costs £187,931 in remaining premiums and provides zero critical illness cover. Our recommended approach adds comprehensive critical illness and key person protection, maintains robust life cover and income protection, and does so through your business with full tax relief. The result is better protection at a lower effective cost — with the peace of mind that your surgical career, your business, and your family are properly covered.

10

How to Proceed

01

Review This Recommendation

Take your time to review the options presented. Consider which cover levels and term lengths best suit your needs and budget.

02

Book a Call with Tom

We'll walk through the recommendation together, answer any questions, and help you decide on the right combination of cover levels.

03

Application & Underwriting

Once you've chosen your options, we handle the entire application process. As a surgeon, your medical knowledge means the health questionnaire should be straightforward.

04

Policy Activation & Review

Your new policies go live and we arrange the transition from your existing cover. We'll schedule an annual review to ensure your protection keeps pace with your career.

Ready to Discuss Your Options?

Book a call with Tom to walk through this recommendation and choose the right protection for your surgical career.

Thomas Hitchcock · Founder/Director · Broadbench Ltd

Excellent

Based on 480 reviews on Trustpilot

"Recently arranged Life Insurance & Critical Illness insurance with Tom. Tom talked through the various options and benefits of both policies which are ideal for me as I am self employed. He arranged comprehensive cover for very reasonable prices which is great for peace of mind. He also dealt with everything from start to finish which saved me a lot of time."

Lee

Jan 19, 2026

Verified

"I had a great experience working with Tom at Broadbench. He was excellent in helping me secure the right insurance policy and took the time to fully understand my needs. As a founder and director of Broadbench, Tom works directly with his clients, which really shows in the level of care and professionalism he brings."

Asfan Khan

Jan 18, 2026

Verified

"I have been with Broadbench a few years now and I have Life Assurance, Critical Illness Insurance, both expensed through my Ltd company, plus they arranged my re-mortgage 5 years ago. Every time Tom has been brilliant — professional, thorough, and always looking out for the best deal."

Yannis N

Jan 22, 2026

Verified

"Tom made the whole process of reviewing my insurance requirements and changing my policy, plus starting a new one for my partner super easy. Reduced what I was paying by over 50% too and now got the protection I need."

Claire

Jun 4, 2025

Verified

"Tom and the team are brilliant. Super clear and informative about what would work best for us as a family. Very easy and pleasurable to deal with. I would highly recommend anyone reading this thinking about working with Tom and Broadbench. You will be in very safe hands."

Edd

Jan 16, 2026

Verified

"Thomas provided an excellent, tailored and personal package that exactly met my needs. His professional and personable approach was key to me having trust in his recommendations."

Mr & Mrs Williams

Jan 9, 2026

Verified

"Reliable, prompt, professional and personable. I've had work and life based insurances through Broadbench for years. Tom is brilliant with checking in and looking at the policies to see if we can better the deal."

Michelle Caunter

Mar 11, 2025

Verified

"I've used Broadbench for both my mortgage as well as life insurance for over 7 years. Tom and his team have been incredibly well informed, conscientious and professional. I have no hesitation in recommending them."

Ahmad Ali

Jan 12, 2026

Verified